Changing spaces

Singapore prides itself for being a highly cosmopolitan and globalised city, with a plethora of well-known international brands and MNCs on the little concrete island. Ion Orchard is the latest development in the heart of the city and is set to be a playground for predominantly the ultra rich and high society folk.

A monstrosity in the City
A monstrosity in the City

But seriously, whats so great about Ion Orchard? Yeah its glitzy, yeah its got all the big labels under one roof… and hell yeah its seems to exude a rather pretentious and socially stratifying environment. The higher up you go in the mall, the higher the prices in the stores.

Few will remember (and perhaps even less) appreciate what existed before Ion Orchard – the lush greenery, which provided some inkling of peace and sanity in the midst of all the concrete in Orchard Road. It was also often a place where many congregated for picnics – especially the migrant Filipino community on the weekend. Indeed, the common public space seemed to cater much more to the layman on the street back then.

But to developers, that green space did not make “economic sense” and was a waste not to be “utilized”. The idea of it being a hang out for migrant workers also perhaps didn’t gel well with the “globalised consumer” image of the surrounding area. The solution: more shops! more malls! buy! buy! buy!

Consumption is rammed into our psyche yet again. But seriously, what proportion of Singaporeans could afford this lavish lifestyle? I know I can’t, being the struggling research analyst and masters student that I am. The point here is not about being a sour plum and criticize those who are economically more well-off, but rather to raise the following concern: How much of the development in Singapore is really catered for Singaporeans?

My cynicism for Ion Orchard (and extreme opulence) has become more apparent after a recent incident, which only served to highlight the stark economic inequalities in Singapore. Yes, there are poor people in Singapore.

Close friends will know how I’ve found this Ramadan to be a lot tougher than previous years – a lot more tired, sleepy, and falling sick for a few days. But my situation is of course nothing compared to that of two people that approached me, as I was walking past Ion Orchard yesterday.

Singaporean #1: An man in his 40s or 50s, who wanted to know how to walk to Ang Mo Kio from Orchard Road. He only had 50cents left in his pocket but wanted to go to church in Ang Mo Kio – a suburb way too far for a walk. He also mentioned later ” two guys I asked just now didn’t help me”.

Singaporean #2: An elderly woman selling pens so that she could “buy some rice to eat”. Looking sad and even tugging on my arm at one point to buy the pens, because other people she asked would not stop to entertain her.

I could not help but think this situation was rather surreal. Nevertheless, the words of my late grandmother kept playing in my head “If someone asks for alms, just give.” as I handed them some money.  Some self-reflection was inevitable as I walked down Orchard Road after the two incidents – Was God testing me/giving me the opportunity to do good on this last day of Ramadan? Although I have seen people asking for help in one way or another along Orchard Road, the odds of having two of them ask within a span of 10 minutes and approximately 50 metres apart would seem rather rare. Are the urban poor of Singapore more obvious now just because of the financial downturn? And moreover, why was it so hard for them to seek help? Are we becoming consumers to the point that we forget to be samaritans? Why is it so hard to exercise that simple universal principle of compassion? 

Food for thought indeed. It has nevertheless made Ramadan for me much more fulfilling.

Eid Mubarak to one and all. 🙂


5 responses to “Changing spaces”

  1. Assalamualaikum warahmatuallah wabarakatuh and EID MUBARAK !

    Dear the Green Bush,

    The more the malls the more the poorers! well Its obvious ! we’re simply killing lives!

    I am so proud of your attitute towards the environment and I am following you …
    But, I need to visit the underground levels of the Ion Orchard where prices get lower !
    Eid Mubarak


    1. Waleikum salam ya akhi!

      Eid Mubarak to you too! Thanks for all your support bro. Yes, I await your arrival so that we can explore this concrete island 😀



  2. Eid Mubarak Sofiah!

    i find it interesting how you have interpreted Ion Orchard as a socially stratified mall.

    you are right that it just doesnt make economic sense to have green-land that does not raise revenue in the heart of orchard road.
    it is disturbing the number of new and upcoming shopping malls in the orchard area..

    do u recall why the road is called orchard road??

    i have heard of a faber castell boutique shop in the upper levels of ion orchard where one can spend lots of money for colour pencils.
    [Point to note: I have not entered the monstrosity called Ion Orchard before]

    the issue is not with the availability of more ‘consumer’ shops that is out of the reach of most public but whether they actually do have enough business to survive economically once the initial rest subsidy duration is over.


    1. Eid Mubarak Ibrahim!

      I believe back in the early days of Brit colonialism in Singapore, Orchard Road was literally an Orchard. As least the footpaths along Orchard road acknowledge this fact with the metal engraved tiles that depict the various fruit trees and spices and other plants that were grown in the area. But might I just insert some cynicism in here yet again – how often would one stop to look at the ground, while standing in awe (or disgust?) of the gigantic shiny buildings around him/her?

      Part of the land was also cemetaries.. I think some parts behind Ngee Ann city which have chinese cemetaries are still preserved. But I believe there were also areas back then that had Muslim cemetaries. Might need to whip out those old history books again! ;-D


  3. Yes, it used to be an Orchard and thus the name Orchard Road. Orchard road used to be a small road, compared to then bukit timah and east coast road, through the orchards.

    i actually do stop to reach those small namesake inscriptions on the ground. because they contain useful bits of information.

    have u tried the history trail around city hall?
    i did one segment of it a few weeks back and it is interesting the monuments in the area!

    i think you are very knowledgeable / aware to know that there used to be cemeteries in that area. most would not know it!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: